May 27, 2007

Do You Speak English ?

I first learned English when I was in junior high. It's not that I wasn't a good student : I just didn't give a damn. Our teacher had been to England once, probably in the fifties. We had this stupid book about three friends, one American, one Irish and one English, and every year we would learn Christmas carols. Needless to say I wasn't paying much attention and spent most of the classes doing my Chinese homework, hidden behind the heater at the back of the room.

English wasn't popular. French don't like English much ("they put vinegar on chips and eat meat with mint sauce !"), and the relationship with the USA has always been a bit rocky ("these warmongers/ burgers-eaters !"), so there were basically no incentive to learn.

In 1999, I spent a summer in Beijing, China. I was 16 and had naively decided I should explore the country I had studied for 3 years. So I packed my bags and left, leaving my parents worried yet proud of their eldest daughter. By the time I landed in Beijing, I had lost my confidence. I had entered a world I wasn't really mastering but I eventually made my way through it. It's in Beijing I met Americans for the first time of my life. I had travelled before in England and in various part of Europe but always with French people, so I never really had to communicate in another language. And now here I was, speechless. My Chinese was fine : beijinren understood me most of time. The same wasn't true for my American roommates and foreigners generally speaking. My first roommate was Indonesian : we had no language in common and she spoke broken Chinese. I felt frustrated and self-conscious : I was the little white girl whose Chinese was better than English. I felt left-out. I swore I would learn English.

When I came back in France, I kept in touch with some friends I met in China. We exchanged emails in English and I slowly improved my writing. I would also listen to a lot of Rock music as I always did, but I would also translate the lyrics. It was a bad idea to start with Pink Floyd and Nirvana : just imagine me lying on my bed, a dictionary in one hand, twisting my hair, trying to make sense of these drug induced
logorrhoea ! By the time I finished high school, I was top of my class in English and was pretty confident in my abilities.

Right after I graduated, I left for Hong Kong, where I somehow managed to get a job thanks to speaking Chinese. Even now, I'm not sure of what I actually did in Hong Kong - this time was really confusing and the place I worked in was odd. Really odd. But selling glass (!) to the world and teaching rich kids didn't leave much room to French, and I ended up speaking English most of time. However, at the time, I hadn't realized I spoke great Cantonese English : "more better" "long time no see", "I tomorrow go to Shenzhen" were the best way to communicate.

Right after Hong Kong, I went to meet Feng in Mexico. We hadn't seen each other since Beijing in 1999 and we were ready for a long trip that would lead us to Beijing. I flew to Mexico. He met me at the airport. It might sound like a clip from a romantic movie. but the romance momentarily paused when, twenty minutes after landing, I declared :

" Please, no English, speak Chinese or Spanish, I don't understand you".

Listening to Feng making conversation on the way from the airport, I had realized something : I couldn't understand a word of what he was saying. I was so used to botched English that proper North American English didn't make much sense to me. Sure, I could pick up a word once in a while, out of a mush of words that I couldn't distinguish. Any question was a struggle. "Do you want to take a shower now or later ?" would be process in my head as "question+shower+later", that was about it. Arguing, making decision or expressing feelings was way out of my league. I never felt that frustrated my whole life, no to mention we were isolated in a Spanish world.

After a couple of weeks, I could understand Feng better, although making a sentence was still taking all of my energy. But I was optimistic : I had almost finished reading an English book, Feng seemed to understand me, I was almost there... right ? I was actually pretty disappointed. In France and in China, I had been considered as "bilingual" and I had expected Feng so mention my fluent English. Okay, on second though, maybe not "fluent". But hey, it was pretty good for a French girl !

So, one night in Cancun, I asked Feng how long it took him to be fluent in English. He paused. I was actually expecting something like "I don't know... coupla years, maybe ?", something reachable, something that would show I was close, very close. He looked up and declared : "probably ten years...".

"That's great", I though. "Not only my English sucks, but I also have to put out with the fact I'm gonna drag my language inability for the next eight years or so. May as well just give up right now !".

But my sign language abilities weren't that good, so I didn't give up and eventually, my English improved. By the time we got back to Canada, I was comfortable enough.

During the next three years, I experienced Kiwi & Australian accent during our South Pacific travels, job hunting back in Canada again, arguments, dealing with all kind of people, working in a call center (where I was so uncomfortable with Quebec accent that I asked to be switched to "English only" calls), and everyday life's problems. I watched TV, read books, learned cultural jokes and bitched about the weather. I swore a lot and cried almost as much. Every new task required more vocabulary, more cultural learning and more slang - none of that was written in a book. I learned first hand that language doesn't come easy and that it takes a lot of confidence to stand up and talk in front of people. I sometimes wished France had invaded the world and forced it to speak French. I dreamed of Esperanto. I loathed people who would look down upon me or those who would throw new words at me.

I feel like I've come a long way. My English isn't perfect but I feel comfortable with it. I can switch back and forth between the two languages when I teach. I'm not scared to talk to people. I can read all kind of medias, watch movies and TV, and - hopefully ! - write in English. I love English as much as I hated it before.

You know the funny thing ? In my first English class back in high school, I laughed when I learned English didn't really have conjugation per se : "wow, that's gonna be easy !"

11 Voices from the world (eh !):

Sebastien said...

You have come such a long way, it's unbelievable! I know what you are saying about English seeming like it'd be easy to learn at first, it's deceptive... my cousins always make me laugh, they say people from the US talk like dogs, as in, very guttural, like, rararara. Makes me laugh every time, it is kind of true, French people speak more from the mouth, US English comes from the throat (at least I think it does...).

I'm thankful I learned English early on, when I was 7. It took a little while to lose my accent and get proficient, but now I regret not having a French accent... actually, I have a slight American accent when I speak French now :(

Dan said...

You sure have come a long way Zhu. I'm amazed that English isn't your first language! Imagine meeting Americans, for the first time, in Beijing! Too funny! :) Hugs. Thanks for linking to me. I have done the same Sweetie!

WAT said...

Your English is quite good my dear. I think the best languages to know are English, Spanish, French, and Chinese.

And it seems as though you're speaking all of those! I'm not speaking Chinese, so I'm a bit jealous.

ErinOrtlund said...

Considering your story, your English (as seen on your blog) is very good!

So if you don't understand/like the Quebec accent, do you teach your students French as it is spoken in France, or have you had to adjust your accent to the Canadian context?

Webmiztris said...

"It was a bad idea to start with Pink Floyd and Nirvana : just imagine me lying on my bed, a dictionary in one hand, twisting my hair..."

lmao!

it seems like you're doing pretty well with the English language now!

Zhu said...

Thanks all for your nice comments on my English ! I actually speak better than I write... I never really had a chance to write in English, that's one of the reason I started this blog ;)


Sebastien : you're right, the way of speaking is very different from one country to another. Some cultures speak with the throat, some with the mouth, some with the nose... yep !

Funny you have an American accent when you speak French ! Last time I went to France, people found I had an accent too :D

Dan : I visited the US first time in 2002 - long after all of my trip... Therefore, I first met Americans in China, I learned about the fast food culture in Salavador (where they have a long avenida with all the US fast food I didn't know about !), I watched all the Hollywood movies in HK... Weird, I know ! :D


Wat
: you're close, just have to learn Chinese now ! My Spanish isn't that good anymore cause I rarely speak it, but I used to be able to have a conversation back in South America.

ErinOrtlund : Now, I know Quebec slang cause I've been there for a while. I can understand it but I won't use it : sounds weird in my mouth...

I usually teach standart French but I give this equivalent in Quebecois when I know it : i.e "déjeuner" (FR), "diner" (QC). People are okay with that...

Accent isn't a problem at all, since not everybody in Quebec has the same accent ! Not to mention all the immigrants... So I just speak clearly and never had a problem, students get used to it.

Webmiztris : Yeah, a very bad idea to start with these bands... But hey, I learned a lot about drugs ! :D

sir jorge said...

My dad still hasn't learned english and he's been in the U.S for 20 years!

I'm impressed that you know so many languages.

I applaud it actually.

I wish I could do more with language, but I haven't really applied myself.

~*SilverNeurotic*~ said...

I would love to be able to learn just one new language, though I find learning languages very difficult...it does help that a lot of the time that you were learning, you were in that environment though. Sitting in a classroom only teaches you so much.

By the way, I've been listening to Nirvana for 10-11 years and I still have trouble figuring out what the hell Kurt Cobain is going on about sometimes. Doesn't help that he never really sang clearly either.

M.A.C. said...

English was born from the Germanic language. Most European language came from an ancient European language called Proto-Indo-European. The language is now extinct but considered the birthing of all the European languages.

English is considered the world language of political negotiation. It is also the international language of science and medicine. There are over 75 Countries that claim English as the official language.

I have spoken English all my living life and still have not mastered its subtle intricacies.

Devil's Son said...

wow...good experience sharing..
and i notice that u actually travelled quite a numbers of asian countries in the past....
cool~~

Deadpoolite said...

I dont speak english it is such a shame....hey wait a minute...did I just write that...IN ENGLISH...nonetheless. It is a miracle, it is a miracle I tell you (there is something supernatural about this blog maybe it is the layout it has to be...back down evil layout and creepy fonts, back down...)

I am Greek by the way and a newbie to your blog, so a big hello to everyone!
Originally I started learning english in my country when I was about 7-8 years old. Then I was bitten by a radioactive bug and decided to go to the UK and study in their higher education (of all the superpowers in the world...).

I wouldnt say english is a hard language compared to some other languages, but I always treated it more like a learning game(even the terminology stuff for my science) so I cant really be objective about the whole thing.

In contrast, it has been so long since I learnt french or actually used them, I always feel annoyed by that.I admit I have forgotten a lot of the vocabulary (oh well no Parisian love for me just yet I guess,lol)

Judging from you blog entry text, your written english is very good and it shows that you have put a lot of work into it. Well done!